CN Rail Spur Line

Because a Canadian National Railways spur line runs through the constituency of Halifax Fairview, and because the CN main line forms the constituency's eastern boundary, I occasionally get railway-related questions. For questions related to the main line, please go to

Spur Line Updates

August 11, 2009

CN Rail Chester SpurMotion Passed

Today, HRM Council passed a motion to purchase the CN Rail line.

By next summer, we should see a crusher dust trail, and by 2011, there should be an asphalt multi-use trail.

You can read the resolution by clicking here.

To read Mayor Kelly's letter to residents near the Chester Spur about the purchase, click here.

The Coast has done an article about the purchase. Click here to read it.

February 10, 2009

Negotiations Ongoing

Last Friday I was told that a CN Rail representative will be visiting Halifax this week to continue discussions with HRM about purchase of the rail spur. Although negotiations have been slow, everyone is still hopeful that the rail spur will eventually become a recreational trail.

March 10, 2008

CN Rail Update

The Halifax Regional Municipality did not, before the statutory deadline of March 6th, put forward an offer to purchase the rail line. Council's discussion was held in private, which is normal procedure when discussing potential land purchases, so there is no public information about their deliberations.

This does not mean, however, that the dream of a recreational trail is dead. Now that the deadline has passed, CN is free to discontinue rail service at any time. However, CN still faces the problem that there are few, if any, viable purchasers apart from HRM. I know that HRM believes the purchase price ($3,306,739) is too high, and that there is room for negotiation. I expect that HRM and CN will continue discussions and negotiations over the coming weeks and months, and I still expect that HRM will eventually purchase the line.

In the meantime, my task is to try to make HRM's decision easier by persuading the provincial government to step forward to assist HRM in its purchase decision.

I would like to thank our local councillors, Russell Walker and Linda Mosher, for supporting purchase of the line.

February 25, 2008

CN Petition Delivered to HRM

Yesterday the results of the on-line petition were delivered to HRM, via its consultant and staff. As of Sunday, February 23, 2008, when the compilation was done, there were 1131 non-duplicate signatures on the petition. A big "thanks" to Bruce Lusby, who sponsored the on-line petition, and to everyone who signed it.

The Trident Cafe & Booksellers on Hollis Street had a hard-copy petition at their checkout as well. I picked it up yesterday and hand-delivered it to HRM's consultant. There were another 111 signatures! Thanks to Trident for joining in the effort.

February 19, 2008

CN Rail Spur Open House

Thanks to everyone who attended the HRM Open House last night at St. Lawrence's Church Hall. What a great turnout on a very wet and windy night. There's obviously strong community interest in the future of the rail line.

For anyone who wasn't able to make it, HRM will be holding another Open House about the rail line on Thursday, February 21st, starting at 9:15 am at the Empire Theatres, 190 Chain Lake Drive, in the Bayers Lake Industrial Park.

February 8, 2008

CN Rail Spur Open House and Petition

Today I sent another update to the area surrounding the CN Rail Spur Line. Read the mailout here.

Open House

HRM is holding an Open House on Monday, February 18th, from 6 p.m. to 8.45 p.m., at St. Lawrence's Church on Dutch Village Road. The meeting notice is on the other side of the letter. You may already have received notice directly from HRM.

This Open House is an excellent opportunity to have all your questions answered, and to let HRM know how you feel about the future of the line.

Petition

A Fairmount resident has started an on-line petition, supporting conversion of the rail line to a recreational trail. Based on the response I've received to my letters, there is overwhelming support for this option. If you would like to join the petition, you can find it here: www.ipetitions.com/petition/cnr_trail. Or simply go to www.ipetitions.com and type CN in the search box. The on-line petition will be followed up on some streets with a paper petition.

If you'd like to distribute the petiton, you may print off the paper form via a PDF file here. Get it back to us by February 15th so it can be presented to HRM council.

For more information go to the CN Railway page or click the link at the top right of the page for more information and updates.

January 17, 2008

Mailout to Area Surrounding the CN Spur Line

On Monday I sent another update to the area surrounding the CN Rail Spur line. You can read it here. Highlights include:

  • CN has issued formal notice of abandonment of the spur line.
  • The federal and provincial governments have declined CN's offer to sell the line to them.
  • The purchase price of the line is $3.6 million.
  • HRM's deadline to tell CN whether it wants to purchase the line is March 6, 2008.
  • HRM is working to develop a plan for an "Active Transportation Corridor" that would connect to the Beechville-Lakeside-Timberlea trail.
  • HRM has issued a Request for Proposals for a development plan and plan for public meetings. Click here for the Request for Proposal. The closing date was January 10.

January 7, 2008

Update on the timeline

Today I received an email from a CN rail official. The following is the current status of the Chester subdivision abandonment process:

CN received no responses to its advertisements seeking buyers interested in purchasing the line for the purpose of maintaining rail service. As a result as per the regulatory requirement, CN offered the line to the various levels of government as well as the public transit authority. Offers to governments were issued on November 01, 2007.

The deadlines for the various levels of governments to respond indicating their interest in purchasing the Chester Spur are as follows:

  • Federal Government - December 03, 2007
  • Provincial Government - January 03, 2008
  • Public Transit Authority - February 04, 2008
  • Municipalities - March 06, 2008

October 29, 2007

Update and Mailout

Today I sent another mailout to the area round the CN Spur Line.  You can read it here. Highlights include:

  • Steps 1, 2 and 3 of the legal process to discontinue the spur are now complete.
  • The next step is for CN to offer to sell the line to the federal government, the provincial government, the urban transit authority, and the municipal government.
  • CN hasn't yet sent the letter of offer.  Once it does, the recipients have time to respond. It may be up to 120 days before all have responded.
  • I have been assured that the Municipality will hold a public meeting.
  • One option for the railbed is a public trail that could connect to the Beechville-Lakeside-Timberlea trail (BLT).

August 22, 2007

I submitted my Chebucto/Parkview News article today. it'll probably be in print in early September. The topic is the CN Spur Line.

Future of rail line presents opportunity, says Fairview MLA

CN is in the process of abandoning the rail line that runs from behind the Joseph Howe Superstore…more

August 20, 2007

I recently received some emails from CN Rail and from the Municipality about the CN Spur Line.

August 1, 2007

I've added some news stories, links to council minutes and other documents where the CN Rail Spur was discussed. They are listed in chronological order on the right, and include:

July 20, 2007

I received a letter from the Minister of Transportation replying to my letter from July 3rd. Click here to read it.

July 10, 2007

CN Rail has applied to discontinue use of the rail spur that runs along Joseph Howe Drive, around the Fairmount and Fairmount Ridge subdivisions, and out to Bayers Lake. Although this is not a provincial issue (at least not directly), I know the application for discontinuance will be of interest especially to homeowners who live beside or near the line. Naturally there will be questions about the future of the line. I am trying to gather as much information as I can about how an application for discontinuance unfolds, and what local homeowners can expect. I will post more information on this site as I receive it.

CNR Spur Line Mailout

Yesterday I sent a mailout to the areas around the CN Spur Line. You can click here to read the mailout. On July 3rd I sent a letter requesting more information about the CN Spur Line developments to the Minister of Transportation and Public Works. You can read it here.

Today I received an email the Department of Transportation and Public Works about the Lakeside Spur Line. The text is below.

Discontinuance of Railway Line Operations and Railway Track

Brief outline of the Canadian Transportation Agency, Transfer and Discontinuance of Railway Line Operations and Railway Track process and description of the rail lines.

CN began the federal Canadian Transportation Agency transfer/discontinuance process by listing the rail line in their three year network plan (12 months prior to notification). CN is proceeding with the following process:

  • The railway line issues a Notice for offers from "interested parties" to operate the rail line, interested parties are required to respond within 60 days. CN issued the Notice June 01, 2007 (response end date July 31, 2007);
  • If there are no expressions of interest the rail line is offered for purchase simultaneously to governments; with offers accepted in the following order:
    • The federal government can make the first offer if the railway line crosses a provincial boundary, first nation Reserve, or there is an outstanding aboriginal land claim (does not appear applicable in the case of Chester Sub.);
    • The provincial government is next with 30 days to respond (Aug.30, 2007*);
    • Municipal government, Halifax Regional Municipality (HRM will have a subsequent 30 days to accept the offer (Sept. 25, 2007*).

*Approx. dates for the Canadian Transportation Agency - Discontinuance process.

Rail Line Description:

CN reported the following tonnages on the rail line.

Year: Car Loadings
2005: 304
2004: 379
2003: 319
2002: 253
2001: 208

CN’s primary rail customers on the Chester Subdivision (4.6 miles) are Taiga Forest Products and Clarke Transport in the Bayers Lake Industrial Park. Their main customer on the Lakeside Spur (0.5 miles) is Russel Metals Inc.

CN Lakeside Spur Line

This line used to run all the way down the South Shore, but now it terminates at the Bayers Lake Industrial Park.

In October 2004, a constituent on Westerwald Street pointed out that the CN right-of-way along Joseph Howe Drive was overgrown and dirty. I contacted CN and on October 21, 2004, I was pleased to see a CN work crew cutting the overgrowth and picking up the garbage. It now looks 100% better. The constituent told me this is the first time the right-of-way has been cleared in at least 10 years.

A constituent on Walton Drive expressed a concern about the future of the railbed if the line is abandoned. I asked CN what their future plans for the line were.

Thanks for your voice message.

The spur line you referred to serves Bayers Lake Industrial Park. We have only a few customers remaining, and the line sees limited use. Nonetheless, we have no immediate plans to discontinue it. Of course, on light density lines and spurs this is subject to change on very short notice.

However, because it is an active line, your constituents need to exercise every precaution when crossing the line at approved crossings and refrain from trespassing.

If you have any further questions, please do not hesitate to contact me by telephone or return e-mail.

Scott Roberts

Assistant Vice-President

Public Affairs & Advertising

Further Reading

May 9, 2008

On Motion for Supply
... I am very pleased to take advantage of this unusual opportunity in the House to take 15 minutes to talk about my constituency, because it ismore

January 17, 2007

CN Spur Line Update and Mailout
The abandonment process has now reached a crucial stage. On November 1, 2007, CN issued its formal notice of abandonment to the three levels of government. The federal and provincialmore

October 29, 2007

CN Spur Line Update and Mailout
On July 9th, I wrote to inform you that CN has applied to discontinue use of the rail line near your home. I am writing now with an updatemore

August 22, 2007

Future of rail line presents opportunity, says Fairview MLA
CN is in the process of abandoning the rail line that runs from behind the Joseph Howe Superstoremore

July 31, 2007

Group fights for rail line preservation
Relieving heavy road traffic and maintaining a significant part of Nova Scotia’s railway history are two reasons why…more

July 20, 2007

Reply from the Minister of Transportation to my letter on July 3rd
Thank you for your July 3, 2007, letter concerning CN1s Notice of Discontinuance of themore

July 9, 2007

Letter to residents around the CNR  Spur Line
CN has applied to discontinue use of the rail line near your home. This is the rail line thatmore

July 3, 2007

Letter to the Minister of Transportation and Public Works about the CNR  Spur Line
It recently came to my attention that CN has formally applied for discontinuance of the rail linemore

July 2007

Chebucto/Parkview News re the CNR Lakeside Spur Line
CN Rail has applied to discontinue use of the rail spur that runs along Joseph Howe Drive, around themore

June 25, 2007

Halifax too small for commuter trains: HRM official
For now, it's a dream - and not a new one, mind you. But still, the idea is intriguing. A commuter railmore

June 19, 2007

Minutes from Halifax Regional Municipality Council re the Spur Line
(Outside Link - go to page 8, section 8.)more

February 2, 2007

BLBA requests meeting over rail line abandonment
Halifax Regional Municipality (HRM) staff is recommending the city not take over the CN rail line known as the Chester Spur…more

January 30, 2007

The HRM Council Report on the Lakeside Rail Spur Abandonment
(Outside Link)…more

December 22, 2001

Safety of bridge questioned
A Canadian National railway bridge spanning Chebucto Road near themore